Since Annie Hall, Woody Allen films have been synonymous with humourous looks
at neurotic New Yorkers (usually including Allen himself) and their disastrous
love lives. Everyone Says I Love You is no exception, featuring enough
psychoses and hang-ups to keep a psychiatrist in business for years, plus a
healthy dose of upper-middle class American angst and soul-searching into the
bargain.
What makes the film slightly out of the ordinary however is that it is a
musical, the characters breaking into old-time song and dance numbers whenever
they get the chance. Although this takes some getting used to at first,
ultimately it becomes a very enjoyable aspect of the movie - particularly the
big choreographed routines. What makes it even more amusing is the at times
inappropriate situations in which the musical numbers feature, such as those in
the hospital or the funeral home. Added to this, the actors themselves perform
the singing duties, with varying degrees of success (Julia Roberts' voice
should be investigated by the military as a potential lethal weapon, for
instance).
Plotwise, the film concerns itself with the lives and loves of an extended
wealthy New York family, and is really little more than a slice-of-life
bittersweet comedy. Full of Allen's usual witticisms and wry observations, and
featuring some great performances from Allen, Goldie Hawn, Alan Alda, Julia
Roberts, Drew Barrymore and Tim Roth (superb as a supposedly rehabilitated
ex-convict), Everyone Says I Love You is an ensemble piece, consistently
lightly amusing without containing any huge belly laughs.
As a musical comedy, the film succeeds on both levels, and the original style
is refreshing and enjoyable without appearing too stilted. If you like Woody
Allen, you'll like the plot and the characters; if you like musicals, you'll
enjoy the songs (with the possible exception of Roberts' calamitous catterwaul)
- in short, Everyone Says I Love You should appeal to those that know what to
expect. It is unlikely however to win Allen many new converts, but I found it
extremely enjoyable and amusing.
Neuroses to music. 9/10