Anarchism and science fiction: B



J.G. Ballard: The Atrocity Exhibition (1970), Crash (1973)

Michael Moorcock’s 1978 article in the Cienfuegos Press Anarchist Review singles out these two works of Ballard’s for inclusion among books which in his view promote libertarian ideas. He comments that they have ‘brought criticisms of ‘nihilism’ against him’ (43). Both works are innovatory in sf, and have an impersonal and amoral quality which perhaps gives rise to such criticisms. They are libertarian in the sense of challenging orthodoxy, of iconoclasm.


Iain Banks: Culture series – Consider Phlebas (1987), Player of Games (1988), Use of Weapons (1990), Excession (1996), Look to Windward (2000)

This popular series showcases an implicitly anarchist post-scarcity society, enabled by nanotechnology.

 

John Barnes: The Man who Pulled down the Sky

‘. . . full of crypto-Anarchism’, according to a poster to anarchysf. ‘The dominant space colony is organized into IWW divisions so to speak. Each group of seven lives together makes communal decisions and lives bisexually with each other as a family unit comprised of seven. The main character is sent back to Earth to start an uprising that is organized along anarcho-communal lines against the Earth Administration.’

 

Robert Barr: ‘The Chemistry of Anarchy’ (in The Face and the Mask, 1899)

Feeble story of cowardly anarchists.

 

John M. Batchelor: A Strange People (1888)

Lost race utopia of atheists and anarchists.

 

L. Frank Baum: The Wonderful Wizard of Oz (1900), The Emerald City of Oz (1910)

‘In the sequels Oz gradually evolves into a state-socialist utopia. The series is worth citing here because it reveals how conceptions of socialism have changed, as Oz has an interesting mix of authoritarian and libertarian features (Baum was influenced both by Bellamy’s Looking Backward and by Morris’s News from Nowhere). (Dan Clore)

 

Barrington J. Bayley: Annihilation Factor (1964)

Includes the character Castor Krakhno, based on Nestor Makhno. (Dan Clore)

 

Edward Bellamy: Looking Backward 2000-1887 (1888), Equality (1897)

Bellamy's influential Looking Backward and its sequel are not in themselves anarchist, but nevertheless attracted the interest of Peter Kropotkin himself. He reviewed the first at great length (extending over four issues) in Le Révolte at the end of 1889, noting that ‘Bellamy's ideal is not ours. But he helps to clarify our own ideas; on many points, without intending to, he confirms them.’ (Pt 1:1). He concluded: ‘Whatever may be the defects of this little book, it will always have done the immense service of suggesting ideas and giving matter for discussion for those who really wish for the social Revolution.’ (Pt 4:2). Lest there be any doubt, though, he stated right at the start of his article that ‘Bellamy n'est pas anarchiste’ (Pt 1:1).Kropotkin found Equality certainly not so interesting, but superior in that it analyses ‘all the vices of the capitalistic system. . . so admirably that I know of no other Socialist work on this subject that equals Bellamy's Equality.’ These remarks on Equality come from Kropotkin's obituary notice of Bellamy in Freedom, translated from Les Temps Nouveaux. His final considered opinion: ‘What a pity that Bellamy has not lived longer! He would have produced other excellent books. I am positive that were Bellamy to have met an Anarchist who could have explained to him our ideal, he would have accepted it. The authoritarianism which he introduced into his Utopia was useless there and contradictory to the very system. It was simply a survival, a concession, a tribute to the past.’

 

J.D. Beresford: What Dreams May Come . . . (1941)

'Dream vision of a non-mechanical, religious utopia.' (Dan Clore)

 

Louky Bersianik: The Euguellionne (1976)

Part 3 appears to express anarchist sympathies (http://feministsf.org/quotes/bersianik.html).

 

Alfred Bester: The Stars My Destination (a.k.a. Tiger! Tiger!) (1956)

Moorcock wrote: ‘This is one of the very few libertarian sf novels I have ever read. That it was the first and turned me on to reading sf is probably the purest accident. [. . .] I know of no other sf book which so thoroughly combines romance with an idealism almost wholly acceptable to me . . .’ (43). He particularly commends the conclusion in which the hero, Gully Foyle, delivers PyrE, the ultimate weapon, to the outcasts of the Earth, for them to repossess their future. Foyle justifies himself: ‘"Who are we, any of us, to make a decision for the world? Let the world make its own decisions. Who are we to keep secrets from the world? Let the world know and decide for itself."’ (Penguin edn, p. 242)

 

Eando Binder: Giants of Anarchy (1939)

? (Dan Clore)

 

Robert Blatchford: The Sorcery Shop: An Impossible Romance (1907)

Fantasy novel influenced by News from Nowhere. (Dan Clore)

 

James Blish: A Case of Conscience (1953); They Shall Have Stars (1955)

A Case of Conscience was discussed by John Pilgrim in his 1963 Anarchy article, for its ethical dimension. The society portrayed, though described by the author as Christian beyond which Pilgrim himself doesn't venture is in many ways anarchistic - an austere kind of Godwinian anarchism, its ethical system rooted in nature, as Godwin argued. Pilgrim also looked at They Shall Have Stars: though he found the plot banal, he considered the novel ‘a powerful attack on authoritarianism, power politics, and the evils of the military mind's concept of security.’ (p. 365). This is perhaps somewhat overstated.

 

Raymond Briggs: When the Wind Blows (1982)

Graphic novel in which an elderly couple experience the dropping of a nuclear bomb in England. Well received at the time by reviewers in two issues of Freedom.

 

John Brunner: Shockwave Rider (1975)

Brunner, interviewed in 1979, said that “if you had to classify me, you'd have to put me in some vague area like ‘fellow-travelling idealistic anarchist.”’ For Lessa, Takver & Alyx, writing in Open Road in 1978, the ‘anarchist city Precipice’ of this work ‘appears like a jewel in a sea of horror’. (13) Congenial and professedly anti-authoritarian as Precipice may be, it cannot fairly be described as anarchist, given that it supports sheriff, mayor, courts, lawyers, and a judicial code with mandatory sentences.

 

Bulwer Lytton: The Coming Race (1871)

William Godwin exerted a degree of influence on Lytton's writing, and Godwin wrote to Lytton admiring his early work Paul Clifford. Godwin even gave support to Lytton when the latter stood for parliament. But George Woodcock notes that though Lytton ‘had a real admiration for Godwin as a philosopher’ he was ‘most attracted to him as a novelist’ (Woodcock 1946:231).The Coming Race is the work by which Lytton is chiefly remembered in science fiction circles. It is a utopia set underground, in which social relations have been drastically modified since the discovery of ‘vril’, an almost magical source of unlimited energy available to every individual. Political power is thus rendered inoperable: ‘Man was so completely at the mercy of man, each whom he encountered being able, if so willing, to slay him on the instant, that all notions of government by force gradually vanished from political systems and forms of law.’ (Steiner pb edn: 56). Marie-Louise Berneri (242) detected Godwin's influence in Lytton's model of a stateless society. Angel Cappelletti (1966:31) additionally hints at some influence from Proudhon. But without suggesting direct influence perhaps Woodcock's suggestion is closest, namely that Lytton's utopia is similar to the world of Stirnerite egoists.

 

Anthony Burgess: A Clockwork Orange (1962); 1985 (1978)

Burgess himself responded in the pages of Freedom to a review by Nicolas Walter of the film of his book. The novel concerns a violent delinquent youth who is forcibly conditioned to non-violent behaviour at the cost of his absorbing pleasure in music; he is eventually reconditioned to his old behaviour patterns. The near-anarchistic moral of the story is made explicit by Burgess in his later work, 1985, which includes comments on A Clockwork Orange: 'The unintended destruction of Alex's capacity for enjoying music symbolizes the State's imperfect understanding (or volitional ignorance) of the whole nature of man, and of the consequences of its own decisions. We may not be able to trust man - meaning ourselves - very far, but we must trust the State far less.' (Arrow edn: 93).'1984' - the first part of Burgess's 1985 - displays an extensive knowledge of the anarchist movement, its history and philosophy. References to the Spanish Civil War or to Sacco & Vanzetti are unusual but not unique in sf, but Burgess's mention' of an anarchist youth movement in China's Yunan province almost certainly is. A chapter entitled 'Bakunin's Children' actually incorporates a three-page biographical portrait of Bakunin, whom he describes as 'the rank meat in a more rational anarchical sandwich, tastier than the dry bread of theory that Proudhon offered before him and Kropotkin after.' (69). Burgess argues that Bakunin's temperament, which urges him to destroy all that is old, led anarchists to reject the past, and that 'Anarchism, in rejecting the past and assuming that the new is, by a kind of Hegelian necessity, better than the old, opens the way to tyranny.'(77) Thus, for Burgess, the world of Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four has its intellectual origins in nineteenth-century anarchism. 'Anarchism is not possible. Bakunin is a dead prophet.' (81) Nevertheless, Burgess clearly finds it appealing: though he says 'you can almost smell the cordite in the word' (69) he finds its overtones 'terrible, and attractive' (71). Essentially it is historical anarchism that Burgess rejects, rather than anarchism's roots in anti-statism and individualism. Having rejected Bakunin and Kropotkin, Burgess opts for Thoreau, 'the true patron saint' (82) of the individual. 'The individual alone can be a true anarch.' (82).

 

William S. Burroughs: The Wild Boys (1969), Cities of the Red Night (1981), Ghost of Chance (1991)

‘While Burroughs work is primarily dystopian, a few anarchistic utopian societies do show up. In The Wild Boys, for example, Burroughs portrays an anarchistic society that consists of roving gangs of dope-smoking, homosexual teenage boys who wear nothing but jockstraps and rollerskates. The trilogy that begins with Cities of the Red Night includes material about several attempts to found libertarian societies, including Libertatia . . . and a group of Rimbaud-reading, dope-smoking, homosexual Zen gunslingers in the Wild West. Ghost of Chance stars Captain Mission and his pirate utopia Libertatia.’ (Dan Clore)

 

Octavia E. Butler: Parable of the Sower (1994), Parable of the Talents (1999)

These two books chart the rise of a (religious) movement based on mutual aid amid an apocalypse in the United States.

 





Authors by surname: A B C D E F G H J K L M N O P R S T U V W Y Z


Bibliography


@sf home, Ben Beck's website home




This page was last revised on 2008-04-02.

© Benjamin S. Beck 20058