Chapter 1 |
Chapter 2 |
Chapter 3 |
Chapter 4 |
Chapter 5 |
Chapter 6 |
Chapter 7 |
| Mind, Mindfulness and Meditation | Solitude | Parental Love and Guidance | Life, Living and Death | Learning and Teaching | Value and Philosophy | Friendship, Relationships and Loving-kindness |
| U.I. and I walk in the evenings for a couple of hours, as usual. Mostly we talk about the nature of mind. Sometimes we talk about what people value most in their lives, and how that shapes and forms both their thinking and feeling. There are good and bad things about everything, everybody, and every place. When we see bad things about a place or a person we should not forget the good things. We tend to see one side only. When we're upset we tend to exaggerate the bad things, and when we are pleased we tend to exaggerate the good things. Adaptability is very important for survival. Rigidity is most dangerous. Compromise in everything except your integrity. You said, "I've changed so much." Well, the process is just beginning. If you don't hold on to your old self-image the change will go on and on. You will feel like a new person, always changing and growing, and you will feel younger too. The old is always old; the new is always young. Learning is quite painful, and acknowledging what is true is also painful but only then do we grow up. You need some distance to see things clearly, to assimilate. When you are too emotionally involved with your experience you cannot understand it. Understand your limitations. You can only do so much. I don't want to put myself into a pigeon-hole; it is too limiting. I want freedom from a name, a label. I am what I am. I don't need to be categorised. Do you know the root of the word 'category'? It comes from Latin and Greek. [LL categoria Gk kategoria accusation. Also; kind of prediction = kategor (os) accuser, affirmer (kategor (ein) (to) accuse, affirm, lit., speak publicly against)]. So, categories (affirming people) are becoming less and less meaningful to me such as Buddhist - that's a category. I don't like being affirmed, either positively or negatively. My mind is becoming more and more free of categories, including good and bad, and things like that. I want to see the real nature of phenomena without naming it. I hope nobody misconstrues me. Why is naming so important? In some cases naming is the same as calling a bad name, accusing. Another thing I want to talk about is regarding expectations. How do we know that what we expect is possible? Why do we need expectations? Why can't we live with what is? Aspirations/ expectations make people feel good. When one (aspires) expects something elevated and good, one thinks that one is a good person. Sometimes aspirations and expectations are self-deceptions. They can also cause disappointment. The Buddha said that when a person becomes an arahat he/ she overcomes views and opinions. How full of views and opinions we are. Yet we are not sure of anything; we're just a lot of talk; a lot of words - blah, blah, blah. Even though I am so loaded with facts and ideas, I still want to know more. My mind is over-crowded, but what is most meaningful, the essence of my learning, cannot be communicated directly and positively by words. I know the superficiality of the world, and I know I cannot do anything about it. Sometimes I am superficial myself. Without mindfulness how can people be other than superficial. I am reading the history book you've sent, Renaissance Europe. It's important to read history to get the wider and deeper understanding of human beings: how ideas and ideals change; how people create dukkha; how attached people are to views and opinions, which always change. Identification with views, religions, and nationality creates so much dukkha and conflict. Self-image creates separation and loneliness. Have you noticed when someone writes something - you know they're writing it from their thinking mind, or from reading about it somewhere else? And when they write it out of their own experience and heart - can you see the difference? Have you ever really given any thought to where your problems come from? And how the web of ignoring the root of the problems has landed you in this situation now? Any pains, any remorse, any regrets? Can you feel for others? If someone can't put themselves in the shoes of others and feel how they feel, what will the consequences be? Have you observed the self-images you could have? Idealised ones, idolised ones, real ones, different ones, which you show to different people. Altogether how many? How can you reconcile them all? How do you put them into one self-image? Or is there such a thing as only one self-image? Then who is this 'big self'? Have you met someone who has the same and constant self-image no matter who they're with and where they are, and in any situation or circumstance? When people start to label you, do you start to believe the labels and live according to what they say of you? How much of their perception of you is right and how much is wrong, erroneous, or distorted? How much of what you see in others is wrong, erroneous, and distorted too? Have you noticed that a number of people who hate evil are likely to be very evil themselves? Why? I have seen many who only watch out for the evil in others but not in themselves. Their own evil, they run away from it. Would it be true to say that by denouncing others they feel superior to those they deem evil and thus the feeling of superiority gives them the false sense that they are not evil at all? A liar can do anything. Do you agree with this statement? How do you feel when a person lies to you? What do you think truth is? When a person transgresses truth, what is he/ she losing? What does one get if one lives a life of lies and self-deception? Can a person grow and develop mentally and psychologically if he/ she does not live a life of truth? What will one achieve if one remains at an infantile stage - emotionally, psychologically, mentally? Is there any real lasting joy and satisfaction in staying at such a stage? How are you going to deal with a person with two very distinct and extreme personalities? One persona is kind and caring; the other is cold, callous, manipulative, selfish, inconsiderate, unthinking, unreasonable, uncontrollable, unrestrained, and destructive. Have you met such people before? I have seen a few and I didn't know how to deal with them. Words are very vague in meaning and communication. Many things can't be communicated using words. In many cases people just use words to impress, but the truth is far from the words themselves. How to know oneself thoroughly? If one does not know oneself, can one know others and expect others to know us? Have you pondered and asked yourself why you do certain things, and with what motivation, or do you just do things because there is a string pulling you to do them, without ever considering whether they are wholesome or unwholesome, harmful or beneficial? Are you controlled by old habits and itches rather than having control over such habits and familiar ways, which are not beneficial or conducive to happiness. Is there such a thing as a fixed personality? Thus, is there such a thing as a leopard which can't change its spots, or can you turn a black crow into a white dove? Are human beings so weak that they won't and can't change for the better but have to be slaves to their old habits and ways? If there is no change, there is no growth. What is forgiveness to you? Do you forgive yourself and others? How much injustice has been done to you? How much injustice have you done to others? Do you think it's worthwhile to rectify your shortcomings and weaknesses, or would you prefer to stay so attached to your old self-images; that it hurts the ego too much if you change? Can you see the benefit of letting go of self-images and the ego which causes so much unhappiness to oneself and others? What is loving-kindness? How to transform it into action in our daily lives? At the end of each day is there a reflection of what one has done, both wholesome and unwholesome? Is there a resolve to avoid further unwholesomeness? How can you solve problems and mysteries if you refuse to acknowledge what it is? Are you courageous enough to call them by their right names and expose them and then walk away from them? Always be very alert. If it is something that you refuse to acknowledge and deny, and you stay away from (fear arises first), this is actually the time when you really need to look at them. They are always in the unconscious and can arise at any time. Do you dare to confront them? Have you noticed that in the beginning it can be very difficult to start something, but after a few tries it gets easier and easier. Like mindfulness practice, in the beginning it is difficult because the mind is attached to old and heedless ways - always careless. But if you keep on persisting, you will see that mindfulness comes quite naturally. Practice makes perfect. Don't you think? How do you see kamma working in your life? Does it work like a boomerang? What is the meaning of life to you? What does life want from you? Why do you think you are here in this existence called life? Do you think it is such a precious opportunity to be born as a human being rather than as an animal or other lower forms of beings? When you do things, do you do it on impulse or do you make decisions after considering the consequences first? Have you noticed how we are often required to make decisions in life? What are the criteria you have in mind when you make a decision? Everyone wants kindness, understanding, love, and compassion from others. How much are we willing to give the same to others? If you had only one month to live, what would you do in that month? What meaning and significance does death have for you? Can life be meaningful and complete without suffering and death? How much have you learnt from suffering - your own and from others? |
We want so much admiration, recognition, respect and love that we think quite a lot about what to do to get them. That way we don't live for what we value most but for what others value most. It is very important to find out what we value most and live it without being in conflict with others if possible. We create values and live them. So it is very important to find out whether those values are really worth living for. Some people think it must be like devaloka (a heavenly realm) to live in B. where you can enjoy all the sense pleasures and where you can get all the luxuries. How hard it is to understand that sense pleasures and luxuries are empty like dreams. I want to have a friend who is not rigidly, blindly and indiscriminately following a set of rules or formulas; who is observant; who lives his life intelligently; who learns and grows as the years go by; who is flexible (who understands a situation and acts accordingly); who wants to find out for himself even the most simple truth (taught by the wisest man in history); who won't take anything for granted (but with due respect), but tries instead to find out for himself; a man who is alive and not lukewarm, who is not afraid to stand alone. What a funny thing fame is - how empty and annoying. When I hear from some friends what people say about me, I don't know whether to laugh or to get upset. What crazy, funny stories people invent. People are stupid and crazy; there is no doubt about that. They want to be deceived, yet they deceive themselves. I know they are basically really nice, simple folks; they don't want to believe the truth, and they are too ready to believe fantastic stories. Why are people so ready to believe fantastic stories? What do they gain by doing so? I enjoyed reading The Illusion of Technique. The Buddha said, 'Ma naya hetu," which means 'Don't believe something (idea) to be true just because it agrees with the system (of philosophy)'. Technique or system is deceiving; techniques and systems are inventions of the human mind. Nature doesn't fit into any system strictly. Even the Abhidhamma [see glossary] cannot really explain natural phenomena completely; it is lacking in many ways. I read them, try to understand them, test them and learn something from them, I know you are disappointed with Western philosophy, and I am not satisfied with it either, but I think I can learn something from them. Most of the existential philosophy is very depressing. They tell you how terrible life is but they can't tell you how to live your life peacefully. Most of the philosophers are all head, muddle-headed. All they do is thinking; they aren't even happy, and many of them went crazy. Most people don't think so much, don't read philosophy, and they're happier than most philosophers. The more I read these philosophies, the more I appreciate the teachings of the Buddha, which are so practical and meaningful. Metta (loving-kindness), karuna (compassion), mudita (sympathetic joy) and upekkha (equanimity), sila (morality), samadhi (concentration), sati (mindfulness) and panna (wisdom) - these things are really meaningful and important in life, and if one develops them, they can really make a difference in one's life. In many ways and for many people, philosophy and science helps a lot to free the mind from dogmatism. That's the best thing about them but they also create a vacuum in people's mind; people are left empty, disillusioned and lost, but can we really blame philosophy and science for that? Philosophy and science helped me to free my mind from believing in my parents' religion yet that left me in limbo also. Now it is my responsibility to give meaning to my life. Reading existential philosophy helps me, in some ways, to understand Westerners and their problems, their way of thinking and what is lacking in their thinking, and how they are trying to solve their problems. Can the teaching of the Buddha help them? How? Understanding others is important in understanding oneself. This world is crazy, absolutely senseless, a fake, a show, a conceited show. Fools get caught in its snare. Vain glory. False possessions.
"So much of my Dhamma connection has fizzled, partly because of my laxness, partly because I've become so disillusioned with the usual forms and institutions." I can understand that very well, my dear friend. My situation is not much different. It is very hard to talk to monks, my former teachers and friends who are monks. I try to understand them and also myself. Metta and karuna I have for them but no deep mutual understanding. There is a big gap between us, and I have no hope of finding a monk with whom I can share my deepest thoughts and feelings and insights. It seems to me that the more you know, the more lonely you become intellectually. Well, anyway, I am not so upset about that anymore although I still yearn for an open communication, free from being judged. I am trying to learn to live with that loneliness; I have to. I feel like I am a star, a million light years away from another star! I think everybody is desperately lonely. Some are more sensitive and so they feel it more. I feel very free in my mind though, with only wholesome and unwholesome thoughts as my guideline. Unwholesome thoughts are painful and are also causes for pain, whereas wholesome thoughts are peaceful. "... there's no vehicle left." Do we need any vehicle? I think if we practice mindfulness in its completeness (not leaving out any part of our life), it should be enough. I want to live mentally free. I might never accomplish anything significant 'in the eyes of others', but I feel OK about that. Internally, however, I feel a kind of freedom which I did not feel before and which most people don't know of. By this I don't mean any stage of enlightenment in its formal sense. My dear friend, you can live a peaceful life if you are clear and wise. Why are you so concerned about others? Do you think you are responsible for them? It is not worth being unhappy about anything. I don't mean I am always happy, but I can see that when there is a big ego identified with something there is also unhappiness. Your words again: "I guess what I'm saying is that I have yet to resolve, within my own mind, the Big Question of what kind of balanced form the practice of the Dhamma can take here in the West, being both true to genuine practice and at the same time meet the strange material needs of this culture." This is a Big Question. Answer this question for yourself first. I think the first and most important thing a person should clearly see in their practice is to see the truth that unwholesome thoughts make a person unhappy. It's not about trying to overcome them, but just to see them plainly and clearly. What do people want? They want happiness and they don't want pain. So see what makes you unhappy. People don't see that it's the unwholesome thoughts which make them unhappy; it's hard for most people to accept that. They think that sensual pleasures and all the things they want can make them happy. If you are happy inside you don't need much to be happy.
What is your most beautiful fantasy? Ah! Beautiful dreams! They made me happy; they nourished me; they were useful when I was young. Now I know they are only dreams. Sometimes I wish I can become dreamy again. Such ignorant bliss! But no that's not possible. I have to climb this mountain, alone, in the bright noon. I long for a companion but, alas, I couldn't get one. I must make my mind and body stronger so that I might be able to climb to the top alone. I know what loneliness means. I'm preparing myself for that. That is my destiny. Sweet, sweet loneliness. My dearest friend, get deeply in touch with yourself. I am less and less inclined to teach, but I'm still interested in talking to intelligent, open-minded people, not to orthodox Buddhists who believe everything in the texts. Worst of all I can't listen to somebody who talks like a preacher, as if he knows everything. If you write your story then I'll read it. A person who is a battleground of conflicting ideals; a Jewish-American Buddhist; a person who knows too much and doesn't know what to do with his life; a person who sees the farce (joke) in the world and can't take anything seriously, including himself, which has become a serious problem for him. (This is true for me too, but I am much more aware of my mind.) "Instead of appreciating your kindness, they think you are cheap, stupid and for use and they start to manipulate. Why?" That's because they have no respect for other people. They have not learnt to have a good relationship with people. Maybe they were never treated with respect. We learn these things from our experience, not from books, maybe they've lived with people, parents, spouse who manipulate each other. It is very hard to find someone who doesn't manipulate others. We manipulate others because we don't trust or respect them, and we don't trust ourselves either. If we respect and trust each other we won't manipulate each other. Manipulation is a sign of weakness and immaturity.
Deception (self-deception) never leads to growth or insight. If you want to see the truth you need courage and honesty first. We are part angel and part demon. If we deny the demon it will haunt us from the dark; let the demon come out into the daylight. Make-believe, maya (illusion), and autosuggestion make life even more empty.
"The tragic issue is the issue of seeing the reality and the truth about oneself. " For those who get distracted easily, it is better to keep their mind busy noting one thing after another; for those who are calm and mindful, they can just watch whatever comes naturally.
If you have nothing to live for it means you value nothing in life, you have no centre. All the ideals you valued were borrowed. In a time like right now, you have no firm ground to stand on. "... one can never apply some centre from the outside." "Difficult as the task is, we must accept ourselves and our society where we are, and find our ethical centre through a deeper understanding of ourselves as well as through a courageous confronting of our historical situation." "And the most constructive place to begin learning how to love is to see how we fail to love." (Rollo May) To forgive is to understand. To forgive is to be free. When you cannot forgive somebody you are in bondage. When you see anatta who is there to forgive. (Sayadaw U Jotika) Here are a few extracts which I find very thought-provoking: "Now it is a well-known psychological tendency that when we repress one attitude or emotion, we often counterbalance it by acting or assuming an attitude on the surface which is just the opposite. You may, for example, often find yourself acting especially politely toward the person you dislike." "Furthermore, if we do not confront our hatred and resentment openly they will tend sooner or later to turn into the one effect which never does anyone any good, namely self pity. Self-pity is the preserved form of hatred and resentment." "... no one can arrive at real love or morality or freedom until he has frankly confronted and worked through his resentment." "Freedom is not rebellion." "Freedom means openness, a readiness to grow; it means being flexible, ready to change for the sake of greater human values." "... man always live in a social world, and that world conditions his psychological health." "The good society is, thus, the one which give the greatest freedom to its people - freedom defined not negatively and defensively, but positively, as the opportunity to realise ever greater human values." "Freedom is man's capacity to take a hand in his own development. It is our capacity to mould ourselves." "... the less self-awareness a person has, the more he is unfree." More awareness means more choice and therefore more freedom. "Freedom is shown in according one's life with realities." "It is doubtful whether anyone really achieves health who does not responsibly choose to be healthy." "Thus freedom is not just the matter of saying 'Yes' or 'No' to a specific decision: it is the power to mould and create ourselves." "Freedom does not mean trying to live in isolation. It does mean that when one is able to confront his isolation, he is able consciously to choose to act with some responsibility, in the structure of his relations with the world, especially the world of other persons around him." "One must make his basic choices himself. "The mark of the mature man is that his living is integrated around self-chosen goals: he knows what he wants." "... the beliefs and traditions handed down in the society tend to become crystallised into dead forms which suppress individual vitality." "The real problem, thus, is to distinguish what is healthy in ethics and religion, and yields a security which increases rather than decreases personal worth, responsibility and freedom. The person in our day, therefore, who seeks values around which he can integrate his living, needs to face the fact that there is no easy and simple way out." "... more accurately, is it not the conflict between every human being's need to struggle toward enlarged self awareness, maturity, freedom and responsibility, and his tendency to remain a child and cling to the protection of parents or parental substitute?" (The message is: Grow up!)
"The problem of being prey to someone else's power is reinforced, of course, by one's own infantile desire to be taken care of." "They have been taught that happiness and success would follow their 'being good', the latter generally interpreted as being obedient. But being merely obedient, as we have shown above, undermines the development of an individual's ethical awareness and inner strength. By being obedient to external requirements over a long period of time, he loses his real powers of ethical, responsible choice. Strange as it sounds, then, the powers of these people to achieve goodness and the joy which goes with it are diminished." "... the person who surrenders his ethical autonomy has relinquished to the same degree his power to attain virtue and happiness. No wonder he feels resentful." "The neurotic uses of religion have one thing in common: they are devices by which the individual avoids having to face his loneliness and anxiety." "... the human being is in the depth of himself basically alone, there is no recourse from the necessity of making one's choice ultimately alone." "... despair and anxiety can never be worked through until one confronts them in their stark and full reality." "Maturity and eventual overcoming of loneliness are possible only as one courageously accepts his aloneness to begin with." "What anxiety makes me now wish to run to the wings of an authority, and what problem of my own am I trying to evade?" "We define religion as the assumption that life has meaning." "Religion is whatever the individual takes to be his ultimate concern." "... psychologically, religion is to be understood as a way of relating to one's existence." "But we do mean to emphasise that unless the individual himself can affirm the value; unless his own inner motive, his own ethical awareness, are made the starting place, no discussion of values will make much real difference." "Love demanded as a payment is not love at all." "We receive love not in proportion to our demands or sacrifices or needs, but roughly in proportion to our own capacity to love. And our capacity to love depends, in turn, upon our prior capacity to be persons in our own right." "The reason we do not see truth is that we do not have enough courage." "When one has been able to say 'No' to the need that he be 'borne up', when, in other words, he is able not to demand he be taken care of, when he has the courage to stand alone, he can then speak as one with authority." "The more a person is able to direct his life consciously, the more he can use time for constructive benefits. To be able to see truth thus goes along with emotional and ethical maturity. When one is able to see truth in this way, he gains confidence in what he says. He has become convinced of his beliefs 'on his own pulse' and in his own experience, rather than through abstract principles or through being told." "The more a person lacks self awareness, the more he is prey to anxiety and irrational anger and resentment: and while anger generally blocks us from using our more subtle intuitive means of seeing truth, anxiety always blocks us." "I have been a learner all my life, but I make truth, which is universal, my own from within, through the exercise of my freedom, and my knowledge of truth is my own relation to truth." "To be capable of giving and receiving mature love is as sound a criterion as we have for the fulfilled personality." "... the most important thing at the outset is to call our emotions by their right names. And the most constructive place to begin learning how to love is to see how we fail to love." "But when 'love' is engaged in for the purpose of vanquishing loneliness, it accomplishes its purpose only at the price of increased emptiness for both persons." "Love, as we have said, is generally confused with dependence: but in point of fact, you can love only in proportion to your capacity for independence." [Most of these quotations have come from Man's Search for Himself by Rollo May or Freedom to Learn by Carl Rogers] |
Chapter 1 |
Chapter 2 |
Chapter 3 |
Chapter 4 |
Chapter 5 |
Chapter 6 |
Chapter 7 |
| Mind, Mindfulness and Meditation | Solitude | Parental Love and Guidance | Life, Living and Death | Learning and Teaching | Value and Philosophy | Friendship, Relationships and Loving-kindness |
Permanent Home for this book is marked RED below.
|
|
||||||||