Abstract

Framework

Historical Context

Differences in Behaviour

Possible Uses for Ochre

Evidence Archaeologically - Europe/Near East

Conclusion

References

South African Sites

Map of  Africa

Chart illustrating the ochre frequency as a percentage of total lithic and pigment assemblages in southern African MSA cave/rock shelter sites. (Knight, Power & Watts 1995)  

Watts (1999a) believes that after 100,000 BP (MSA2b) there is some evidence for activity differences between shelters, seen in the dramatic increase of ochre.  

Blombos, South Africa  

Evidence of Middle Stone Age people is thought to have been found here due to the large amount of ochre excavated at this site, assumed to have been used for body painting during ritual activities (Website:  New Finds at Blombos: http://cogweb.english.ucsb.edu/EP/Blombos.html).  Hunter-gatherers at approximately 80,000 years ago are found to be behaviourally similar to 40,000 to 30,000 years ago (ibid).  Hundreds of lumps of ochre have been found at Blombos together with powder traces on stone and bone tools (ibid). 

Bone point, broken at distal end.  Length 55mm.

Ground to a point and highly polished.

Patches of what appear to be ochre are visible in the polish.

(Henshilwood & Sealy 1997:893)

Many of the pieces of ochre seem to have been ground and worked (New Finds at Blombos: Website).  Ian Watts states that “the most intensively ground pieces take the form of crayons … some are beautiful and the implication of such honed points is that they were used for design” (ibid).   Dr Henshilwood believes the occupants of the Blombos cave used ochre for body paint (ibid).  Although helpful, one should be cautious when drawing an analogy to contemporary hunter-gatherers and prehistoric people, as we do not know whether their ritual activities, affected by their socio-political pressures of the time, are the same. 

   

 

  Body art:  Mazai warriors wearing ochre body paint

  which has been in use as far back as the Middle Stone Age

(http://cogweb.english.ucsb.edu/EP/Blombos.html)  

In a recent television series, Ape.man (2000), Henshilwood points out storage pockets carved out of the side of the cave where ochre was found (McBrearty & Brooks 2000:528).  These samples had striations demonstrating use and a patch of red pigment on a nearby rock was tested to be ochre.  Henshilwood believes that the ochre must have been used to decorate bone tools or stone artefacts and decorate bodies.  An ochre stained gouge was found with finger and thumb imprints.  The series of cut marks on ochre and lines creating a mesh design are thought to be deliberate attempts at art or some type of symbolic gesture.  There was no trace of naturally occurring ochre.   

Brian Hayden (1993) agrees that ochre could be another method for solving the puzzle of human behaviour but does not go further to express its significance or what the behavioural implications may be for the grinding of ochre or notches.  No attempt seems to have been made to actually test this mineral for heat transformation of colour, or whether it was from the immediate geological context.  

Klasies River Mouth, South Africa  

The technology in Howieson’s Poort layers (c. 70,000 BP) is more sophisticated, and lithic technology is thought to be unique for its time as it is not found anywhere else until much later in the Late Stone Ages.  Mithen (1998) notes that there seems to be an increase in the quantity of red ochre after 100,000 years ago in the form of crayons at this site.  Throughout all the Howieson’s Poort Industries a few small pieces of soft, oxidized rocks were found which would have been suitable for the production of pigments (Singer & Wymer 1982:117).  Most of them showed signs of smoothing or scratching, occasionally so well developed that they could be described as crayons (ibid).  The raw material varied from the harder highly oxidised sandstone similar to materials occurring in cracks within the local quartzite found naturally at the site to a softer, greasy haematite that must have been imported (Watts 1999b: 119).  Ochre stained grindstones are reported from Klasies River, suggesting the processing of this material to make powder for paint (Watts 1999b:142).  An experiment was conducted mixing the ochre powder with some fat and then painting it onto some local beach pebbles.  It is not mentioned how long the pebbles were exposed to rain and sun but the paint remained fast (Singer & Wymer 1982:117).  A piece of red ochre has been found in the Howieson’s Poort level with drill marks and signs of grinding, strongly suggesting symbolic traditions (Knight, Power & Watts 1995:87).

             

                                          

  Drilled and ground red ochre.

  Knight, Power & Watts (1995)

  Gouged red ochre. 

  Knight, Power & Watts (1995)  

 

                 

  Ground and gouged red ochre.

  Knight,Power & Watts (1995)

 

  Haematized shale “crayon”.

  Watts (1999a)

 

 

Singer & Wymer (1982) do not believe that there is evidence to indicate for what purpose the red paint was used.  The inference is that it was for artifactual or personal adornment and it suggests that colouring materials were considered of great value and were possibly regarded as imparting magical rather than just decorative qualities (Singer & Wymer 1982:117). 

Lindley & Clark (1990) suggest that although ochre was found dispersed throughout the Middle Stone Age (MSA) levels, evidence for symbolic behaviour is “both equivocal and scarce”, and that there is no indication of a pattern in its occurrence.   

Die Kelders Cave 1 (Klipgat), South Africa

At this cave site there is a long Middle Stone Age sequence preserved between the Later Stone Age layers and a cobble beach on bedrock (South African Museum Homepage: http://www.museums.org.za/sam/resource/arch/klipgat.htm). Although there is a possibility of a Howieson’s Poort industry, further excavation awaits a larger sample to confirm this, but some believe that it is missing and that the overall impression is one of minimal change over time (ibid).  Red ochre occurs as nodules, often with signs of abrasion (Grine et al. 1991:368).  Hearths were located throughout the Middle Stone Age sequence and the diet is in line with Klasies River main site and Blombos Cave (ibid).  One of the Middle Stone Age artefacts from Die Kelders is a quartzitic sandstone upper grindstone, which has ochre staining (McBrearty & Brooks 2000:528).

 

(Avery et al 1997 :275)

 

Four to Five meters of iron-stained sands are rich in bone and MSA artefacts (Grine et al. 1991:365).  

Twin Rivers, Zambia

Barham (1998) has been very close to applying the methodological framework proposed in this paper by properly recording the ochre found at this site.  He has provided the dimensions, colour using the Munsell chart, the hardness of the mineral using Moh’s scale and the texture (internally and externally) of the four pieces of ochre found (Barham 1998:705-706).

               

Large haematite flake with broken tip (lower left) showing wear (A Block).

(Barham 1998)

Cut mark on the striking platform of haematite flake (A Block)

(Barham 1998)

                                                                  

    

Split and flaked haematite artefact from A Block.

(Barham 1998)

Limonite with wear facet from top left to bottom right (F Block).

(Barham 1998)

 

Split haematite artefact from A Block

(Barham 1998)  

Testing of staining on worn tools from Clark’s earlier excavation has proven that it derived from the same processing pigments.  A limited survey of the local area for the source for the pigments resulted in a poor source of haematite at the base of the hill, which would not have been accessible without extensive quarrying and processing (Barham 1998:707).  Barham (1998) believes that further surveys, to plot the distribution of source material, will provide evidence to assess the degree of planning involved in procuring these materials.

In subsequent excavations Middle Stone Age artefacts were recovered with a large quantity of many different coloured pigments derived from locally available minerals. Only nine of the 307 pieces excavated “show signs of having been rubbed or ground to reproduce, presumably, a powder…unambiguous evidence of the systematic collection and processing of pigments over a long period” (Barham 2000) and he believes that a particularly hard type of iron oxide was collected for its colour, and ground although a softer material was available nearby.  Barham associates pigment use with group activities such as ritual, language assuming the “capacity to generate culturally mediated symbols and, indirectly, the development of syntactic language”, chain-reacting to “use of symbols indicating self-awareness”, “belief systems”, “group identity”, “female reproductive strategies” etc. (Barham 1998:208). It is assumed that the pigments were used primarily for ritual body painting, and perhaps for cave painting as well, although there is no direct evidence. 

Border Cave, Swaziland

The bones of an infant stained with ochre were found (Rudgley 1999:178) and the dating of the accompanying shell “pendant” estimates that the burial took place 100,000 years ago (Mithen 1998:23).  Fibrous material, found in an MSA context, stained with iron oxide has been interpreted as bedding material (McBrearty & Brooks 2000:528).  Mithen (1998:208) suggests that the most likely explanation for the large amounts of ochre found at this site, is body painting.   Beaumont et al (1978:37) suggests that among the varieties of pigment encountered throughout the MSA sequence at Border Cave, some seem to have been transported considerable distances.  Howieson’s Poort industries date between 45,000 and 75,000 years ago (Mithen 1998:283).  

Sediments have been macroscopically examined and colour coded using the Munsell Soil Colour chart (Butzer et al. 1978:318).    

Sedimentological data for Border cave from Butzer et al 1978:322.

 

Bushman Rock Shelter, Eastern Transvaal

This site is dated 43,000 to 47,000 BP where grinding stones retaining traces of ochre have been found.  This has been interpreted to have been used for processing ochre to make powder (Rudgley1999:178).  

Olieboompoort, South Africa

Volman (1984) feels that it is unlikely that the rare MSA grindstones served primarily for processing pigments, only one of the five grindstones from Bed 2 at Olieboompoort preserves traces of ochre.  Caching of glittery Specularite at this site is thought to be evidence of effective sensory stimulus to heighten “the experiential impact of ritual” (Watts 1999a:129).

Specularite “crayon” from Olieboompoort Bed 2, MSA2b

Watts (1999a)  

 

 Specularite “crayon” from Olieboompoort Bed 2, MSA2b

Watts (1999a)