The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes - based not on a Conan Doyle story but on a play
based upon his characters - was the second movie to feature the classic portrayals
of the London detective and his assistant: Basil Rathbone as Holmes, and Nigel
Bruce as Dr Watson.
Rathbone in particular has become the Sherlock Holmes, with his
piercing eyes, knife-sharpened features and finely-played trademark habits (the violin, the
relentless drive and enthusiasm, the never-ending desire for knowledge). Bruce's Watson is also the stuff of movie legend, and
he plays the character as a perfect humourous foil to Rathbone's intense
seriousness - although Holmes himself is not averse to the odd witty quip. In
short, these two actors made the roles their own, and it will take a very
convincing and impressive performance to ever dislodge them.
The plot of the film is classic Holmes fare, concerning the devious Professor
Moriarty (the stage villainry of George Zucco) and his plot to commit a classic crime, one that will go down
in history. Involving mysterious notes, South American flute players, the
Tower of London and the fog-filled streets of 1890s London, the plot contains
all the requisite ingredients of a typical Holmes story. And of course, the solution is elementary.
Succeeding in evoking the deep, dank pea-soupers of the capital city, the film
has a deliciously atmospheric tone: all hansom cabs and gas streetlights, enshrouded
in luminously swirling fog. Through these scenes, Holmes and Watson rush with
great enthusiasm and infectious determination, the direction suibtably fast-paced
and thrilling, leading up to a climactic conclusion.
The Adventures Of Sherlock Holmes is a classic crime mystery, enriched by
classic performances and a well-written and amusingly wry script. Even though
not taken directly from a Conan Doyle story, you sense that the author would be
very satisfied by this faithful and accomplished recreation of his much-beloved
creations.
Elementary. 9/10